Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood
"* " Single player is pretty short, although the two characters play just different enough that you may be able to justify two playthroughs (and there's achievements for going straight through as each character without switching.)
- Knives are useless, the bow's the best weapon.
- Quickdraw duels are finicky, you circle to keep the guy in view and the other stick positions your hand before the signal to draw. I still can't do it with consistency and I finished the game 2 weeks ago.